The Advance of Belief: Why Opportunity Often Comes Before Proof
Recognizing potential before proof exists can be an important act of judgment, commitment, and responsibility, because records usually begin with an opportunity that no record has yet earned.
Abstract
Accomplished people often thank those who believed in them early. The popular explanation is that belief unlocks ability.
The evidence supports a narrower claim. Expressed confidence can raise effort, but its effects vary.
A second mechanism matters more for careers. Some people transfer credibility, opportunity, or resources before sufficient evidence exists. This essay calls that an advance of standing.
Such advances address the First Credit Problem. A person cannot earn a record without an opportunity, and institutions rarely grant an opportunity without a record.
The essay draws on studies of hiring, research funding, and early-stage finance. It reads three cases: Dr. Hayat Sindi and her father, G. H. Hardy and Srinivasa Ramanujan, and James Mattis at Theranos.
It proposes The Advance of Belief. Three conditions describe responsible belief: Seen, Staked, and Standard. One outcome describes its success: Converted. Responsible support can still fail.
The cost of belief shows commitment. It does not establish accuracy.
The central argument is plain. Early belief matters most when it is a considered judgment, backed by commitment, that creates a chance to build independent evidence.
The Person Who Believed First
In June 2010, Dr. Hayat Sindi addressed the Society of Petroleum Engineers in Alkhobar. Her father had died four months earlier. She recalled what he told her when she left for Britain: "Don't let me down." She said she hoped she had made him proud.
The story she has told over the years did not begin with that sentence. She grew up in Makkah in a family of eight children, and she recalls a father who brought her library books and discussed them with her. When she asked why she could not see anyone like her among great scientists, he told her that education could take her anywhere.
Then she wanted to study abroad. By her account, she told him a London university had accepted her, though none had. She recalls his answer: "Over my dead body." He worried, she said, about the family's honor if she lived overseas alone. In one telling, the persuasion took two years, until her parents saw how unhappy she was and did all they could to enable her to go.
On her first night in London, she recalls, she sat panicked in a hostel attic. She looked at her plane ticket and saw that her father had bought a return. She thought she would go home the next day.
She stayed. Universities turned her down, so she spent a year on English and A-levels, then entered King's College London and graduated in 1995. Cambridge later offered her a grant, on condition that she pass a first year in engineering she had never studied. She recalls opening the letter in a car with her father beside her and asking what she should do. He asked where her heart was. She said biotechnology. "Then it's Cambridge," he said.
She says a well-known scientist there gave her three months before she would fail. She completed her doctorate in 2001, and is widely reported as the first woman from the Gulf to earn one in biotechnology.
When her father died, she says, she found newspaper clippings about her under his pillow.
Evidence note. Her degrees are documented. The rest of this account is reported recollection: every telling is retrospective, the earliest from 2004, and they differ in emphasis, from "over my dead body" to "supported me fully." The essay treats them as one person's memory of a process, not as an independently verified sequence.
Dr. Sindi attributes her achievements to her own commitment, and says, "Nobody wanted me but I always believed in myself." Her ability is now visible, and her accomplishments are well documented. Why, then, do accomplished people keep returning to the person who believed first?
The First Credit Problem
The answer begins with a practical trap. A person cannot earn a record without an opportunity, and institutions rarely grant an opportunity without a record. This essay calls it the First Credit Problem.
It is not only a matter of personal struggle. Michael Spence (1973) modeled how employers rely on signals when they cannot observe ability directly. A first-timer may have the ability and still lack the signal. Sound screening can therefore exclude capable people without anyone making a careless decision.
Hiring. Amanda Pallais (2014) tested part of this on an online labor market. From 3,767 applicants, she randomly hired 952 and gave them public evaluations. Among inexperienced workers given a basic evaluation, employment two months later rose from 12 percent to 30 percent. These workers had not been chosen for promise, so the first opportunity itself appears to have created the evidence the market wanted.
Early-stage investment. Sabrina Howell (2017) compared firms just above and just below the award cutoff in a US Department of Energy grant program. An early award roughly doubled a firm's chance of later receiving venture capital. Howell concluded that the grant's value as a quality signal probably does not explain this. The money seems to have helped firms build prototypes, which gave investors something to examine.
Academic funding. Thijs Bol, Mathijs de Vaan, and Arnout van de Rijt (2018) studied 3,660 applicants for Dutch early-career grants. Over eight years, researchers just above the funding cutoff won more than twice as much further funding as those just below it. They were also more likely to become full professors, at 28 against 19 percent. Near-winners applied for the next grant less often. Small early differences grew, a pattern Robert Merton (1968) called the Matthew effect.
Leadership. Herminia Ibarra, Nancy Carter, and Christine Silva (2010) studied high-potential professionals and distinguished mentors from sponsors. A mentor offers advice. A sponsor uses influence with senior leaders to advocate for someone. Their findings are correlational, so they describe sponsorship without establishing its effect.
These sources need careful handling. The hiring and funding studies measure what follows when an opening appears. They do not measure interpersonal belief or reputational sponsorship. Their lesson is limited but important: the first opportunity can produce evidence, not merely reward evidence that already exists. Connecting that finding to belief is this essay's inference.
They also carry a warning. If near-identical people can end up far apart, the choice of who receives first credit matters a great deal. Early support can correct an evaluation system's blind spot, and it can also compound favoritism. The question is therefore how such a decision can be made responsibly.
What Research Tells Us About Belief
Openings explain why first credit matters. Belief enters as one way people decide who receives it, and as a force of its own. The best-known research suggests that expectations alone can do remarkable things. Dov Eden and Abraham Shani (1982) told instructors in a 15-week Israel Defense Forces course that certain trainees had high command potential. The labels were assigned at random among 105 trainees. Those labeled high scored significantly higher. Eden attributes such results to changes in how leaders treat people.
Brian McNatt's (2000) meta-analysis of 17 management studies found a large average effect (d = 1.13). That figure needs context. Effects varied considerably, were stronger in military settings and among men, and were stronger for people initially held to low expectations. Ongoing jobs have also received less study than training settings.
Classroom evidence is cooler. Lee Jussim and Kent Harber (2005) reviewed 35 years of research and found typically small effects that do not accumulate greatly. They also found that teacher expectations may predict outcomes partly because they are accurate. Powerful effects may appear among students from stigmatized groups. Belief may matter most where others have already formed a low opinion.
Albert Bandura (1977, 1997) offers one explanation of the limits. People draw their sense of capability mainly from their own mastery. Persuasion from others is weaker, and it helps most when the appraisal stays "within realistic bounds." Words cannot replace mastery. They can keep someone in the work long enough to reach it.
This research describes psychological belief: expressed expectations that influence motivation, effort, and behavior. It works, within limits, and it can work at little cost to the believer.
An advance of standing is different. It is a commitment that transfers credibility, opportunity, or resources before sufficient evidence exists. The two often appear together, but they are separate mechanisms. Dr. Sindi's father appears to have supplied both.
When Belief Becomes Consequential
In 1912, Srinivasa Ramanujan was an accounting clerk at the Port of Madras, earning a modest salary and filling notebooks with mathematics. Friends and colleagues tried to help, but they struggled to judge him. A London professor concluded that he had some ability but had gone down wrong lines. According to John Littlewood's later account, two Cambridge mathematicians, H. F. Baker and E. W. Hobson, did not respond to his approaches.
On 16 January 1913, he wrote to G. H. Hardy. The package held more than 120 results, some of which seemed absurd. Hardy had reason for caution, and he and Littlewood wondered at first whether it might be a practical joke. They worked through the results anyway.
Some they knew. Some they could not place. They concluded that those "must be true because, if they were not true, no one would have the imagination to invent them."
Hardy's reply did not celebrate. He wrote that he was "exceedingly interested," then added that he needed proofs before he could judge properly. Ramanujan answered with a mixture of hope and fear. He wrote that Hardy might point him to a lunatic asylum, and he told Hardy, "I am already a half starving man."
Hardy began asking how to bring him to Cambridge. Ramanujan's Indian supporters pressed the University of Madras, whose regulations did not allow a graduate scholarship for someone without a degree. A route through government approval was found.
Trinity College would not provide real funding, so Hardy and Littlewood offered some of their own money. E. H. Neville, while lecturing in Madras, helped overcome Ramanujan's objections, and told Hardy that financial difficulties "simply must not be allowed to interfere." Hardy later credited Neville with overcoming the serious obstacles.
The standard did not soften. In December 1913, Hardy told him his ambitious claims about prime numbers were incorrect. After Ramanujan arrived in 1914, Hardy rewrote his earliest manuscripts. He later wrote that he feared systematic teaching might destroy Ramanujan's confidence, but judged that some errors had to be corrected. He also conceded, "obviously I learnt from him much more than he learnt from me."
In 1918, Ramanujan became a Fellow of the Royal Society and of Trinity College. Baker and Hobson were among those who supported the Royal Society election. Ramanujan was seriously ill by then, and he died in India in 1920, aged 32. Hardy later called the association "the one romantic incident" of his life.
Evidence note. The letters, dates, and elections are documented. Littlewood's account of the unanswered approaches came decades later. Hardy's and Neville's statements are their own retrospective accounts. The reading that follows is the author's inference.
Hardy did not create this talent. The notebooks came first, and Madras supplied supporters before Cambridge did. What Hardy supplied was an informed judgment that institutions could accept, along with effort, money offered, and reputation attached. This is a clear example of an advance of standing. The case also shows why belief alone explains little: his contribution depended on his being able to read the work.
Belief With a Standard
Hardy's demand for proof might look like the opposite of belief. A set of classroom experiments suggests the two can belong together.
David Yeager and colleagues (2014) studied how students respond to critical feedback. In their first study, 44 seventh graders with B and C averages received teacher comments on an essay. A randomly assigned note came with the comments. One note simply said the comments were feedback. The other said, "I'm giving you these comments because I have very high expectations and I know that you can reach them."
The outcome was whether students chose to submit a revision. Among the 22 African American students, 64 percent revised after the second note, against 27 percent after the first. Adjusted for covariates, the figures were 71 and 17 percent.
White students also revised more often, at 82 against 64 percent in raw terms, but that difference was not statistically significant. The authors call some subgroup findings tentative because the samples were small. A later small study of university students did not replicate the effect where trust was already high (Troy et al. 2024).
This case does not demonstrate an advance of standing. The note cost almost nothing, and random assignment means it could not have responded to anything specific in a student. No teacher risked credibility or transferred any opportunity. It supports the psychological mechanism, and it should not be stretched further.
It contributes one important finding. The effective note paired confidence with a high bar, and its effect was strongest among African American students who reported low trust in school. For someone uncertain whether they are respected, a high standard can communicate respect. Lowering the bar can communicate the opposite.
When Belief Goes Wrong
Even a substantial personal stake leaves a critical question unanswered: is the judgment sound? In 2013, James Mattis was a four-star Marine general close to retirement. He had met Elizabeth Holmes, and he had seen a finger prick demonstration of the blood test she was developing at Theranos. He wrote to her, "I'm strong believer in what you have designed/built."
Holmes invited him to join her board. He testified that he asked why, because he was "not a medical person." He testified that she wanted help building a corporate culture. He joined, and he bought two books and two pamphlets on being a board member.
He also staked something real. He invested $85,000 of his own savings and testified that this was significant for someone who had spent 40 years in government. He wanted "skin in the game." He testified that he offered to serve for free, telling her, "I believe in what you are doing." He also recognized the larger stake: "We were putting our reputation at risk."
In 2015, The Wall Street Journal reported serious flaws in Theranos's testing. Mattis left the board in 2016 and later testified that board members had been "deprived of fundamental issues." In January 2022, a jury convicted Holmes of defrauding investors.
Evidence note. The conviction is court record, reported here through journalism. Mattis's statements are sworn testimony and remain his account. Holmes maintained at trial that she believed in the technology.
Responsibility for the deception lies with those convicted of it. The case still exposes a flaw in a common assumption. Spence's logic says costly signals are harder to fake. Mattis's commitment was costly and sincere, yet the claim it supported was false.
This produces a central principle. The cost of belief demonstrates the seriousness of the believer's commitment. It does not establish the accuracy of their judgment.
The contrast with Hardy is not one of sincerity. Hardy could read the mathematics, had Littlewood beside him, and demanded proofs. Mattis, on his own description, was not a medical person, and he testified that the board was deprived of fundamental information. This does not make all outside board members negligent. It shows that judgment has to rest on some means of checking the work.
Pierre Bourdieu (1986) explains why this matters beyond one investment. Recognized standing can pass from one person to another by association. A respected name can lend credibility it has no means to test. Others may then read the lender's commitment as evidence about the claim, when it is evidence only about the lender.
The Advance of Belief
The cases point toward a model of how early support can be responsible. It is a proposed framework. The cases illustrate it, and they do not test it.
The Advance of Belief is standing lent to someone before they can fully earn it. Three conditions describe the act of lending. A fourth term describes the result.
Conditions of responsible belief
Seen. The belief responds to something specific, and the believer has some means of judging it. Two kinds of knowledge qualify, and they justify different things. Technical knowledge judges the work: Hardy could read the formulas. Personal knowledge judges the person's potential, character, and persistence: Dr. Sindi's father, on her account, had discussed books with her for years.
Personal knowledge can justify giving someone a chance to try. It cannot vouch for a technical claim. Her father did not need to assess biotechnology to back her, because Cambridge set its own test: pass the first year in engineering. Mattis's personal impression of Holmes, by contrast, could not tell him whether a blood test worked.
External verification is therefore needed when a claim rests on expertise the believer lacks, when others will rely on the believer's name, or when third parties bear the risk. Without Seen in either form, support becomes flattery or favoritism.
Staked. The believer commits something of their own: money, time, access, or reputation. The stake makes the support real and gives others a reason to pay attention. It says nothing about whether the judgment is right. Without this condition, support remains encouragement.
Standard. The bar stays high after support begins. Hardy asked for proofs. A father told his daughter not to let him down. Without this condition, support can become indulgence, and it can deprive a person of the information they need.
The outcome
Converted. Borrowed credibility becomes independently demonstrated capability: a paper, a degree, a result that others can verify without the lender.
Conversion is an outcome, not a requirement of the original decision. A person can receive responsible support and still fail. An illness, a market, a closed door, or plain insufficiency can intervene. A believer who saw clearly, committed seriously, and held the standard made a sound decision even if the result never came. In the other direction, a poor decision can sometimes convert by luck.
This matters because hindsight distorts judgment. We tend to call belief wise when it worked and foolish when it did not. The framework asks a different question: what could this person reasonably know, what did they commit, and what did they require?
What each case contributes
| Case | What it shows | Where it stops |
|---|---|---|
| Sindi and her father | Support that developed over time and carried real personal stakes | Rests on recollection, and cannot separate his effect from her own determination |
| Hardy and Ramanujan | An advance of standing grounded in expert judgment | An exceptional talent with many supporters, not a typical case |
| Wise feedback | Psychological belief, paired with a high standard, can change effort | Does not involve an advance of standing |
| Mattis and Theranos | A real stake does not establish accuracy | Involved deception, so it cannot show how far diligence alone would have gone |
From encouragement to evidence
The practical lesson is not to believe in more people. It is to know which act you are performing.
| The act | What it provides | The question to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Encouraging | Confidence and persistence | Is my appraisal realistic, and specific to this person? |
| Providing an opportunity | A real chance to produce evidence | What will they do that they could not otherwise do? |
| Extending credibility | Access through your name or your institution's | Could I defend this judgment, and have I tested it? |
| Establishing a standard | A clear bar and honest feedback | What exactly would count as meeting it? |
| Evaluating independence | Evidence of capability | Would this result stand if my name were removed? |
Each audience can use these acts differently. Hiring managers can create small, real assignments that produce work others can evaluate. Investors and funders can pay for the prototype that generates the evidence they want to see. Academic bodies can record who was narrowly declined, because the people just below a line may be close to those just above it. Boards and leaders can name who sponsors each high-potential person, what evidence supports that sponsorship, and when others will review it.
For institutions, an advance of belief is a way to recognize potential that a standard evaluation cannot yet read. The University of Madras had rules, and someone had to find an accountable route around them. The safeguard against favoritism is not the removal of judgment. It is making judgment specific, testable, and answerable to a later review.
Limits
Survivorship. The essay's stories come largely from people who succeeded. Sincere advances that failed rarely reach print. The available evidence does not establish how frequently accomplished people credit early supporters, or whether they do so more often than others.
Causation. Gratitude is testimony about what a person remembers as decisive. It cannot show what would have happened otherwise. The opportunity studies support claims about opportunity and evidence, not about the effect of any particular believer.
Accuracy. A believer may simply spot someone who was going to succeed anyway. Yet spotting is not always neutral when it also opens access, and the Dutch funding evidence suggests access can matter by itself.
Self-belief. Some people proceed against all opinion. An advance is not necessary for every achievement. The claim is narrower: it can matter when a capable person lacks a record and needs an opening.
Why We Remember
Why do accomplished people remember those who believed in them before there was proof? One reason is that later success cannot return them to that moment. Records eventually persuade the market, the board, and the institution. They cannot reproduce the time when someone had to decide without them.
Three things happened in that time. Someone recognized potential before conventional evidence existed. They acted on that recognition, often at a cost to themselves. Their support then created a chance for the person to build a record that no longer depended on them.
That is more demanding than encouragement. Encouragement is what someone says. An advance is what someone risks. Dr. Sindi's father could have kept her at home and protected the family's name as he understood it. Hardy could have treated one more strange letter as one more crank.
None of this proves that either outcome depended on them. Ramanujan had the mathematics, and Dr. Sindi did the years of work. Thanks does not settle that question. It records something else: the person remembers being taken seriously when there was little evidence to justify it.
Long after the record can speak for itself, they remember who spoke before it could.
References and Further Reading
Academic
- Bandura, A. (1977). Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change. Psychological Review, 84(2), 191–215.
- Bandura, A. (1997). Self-Efficacy: The Exercise of Control. W. H. Freeman.
- Bol, T., de Vaan, M., & van de Rijt, A. (2018). The Matthew effect in science funding. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 115(19), 4887–4890. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5948972
- Bourdieu, P. (1986). The forms of capital. In J. Richardson (Ed.), Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education (pp. 241–258). Greenwood.
- Eden, D., & Shani, A. B. (1982). Pygmalion goes to boot camp: Expectancy, leadership, and trainee performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 67(2), 194–199.
- Hardy, G. H. (1921). Srinivasa Ramanujan (obituary). Proceedings of the Royal Society A, 99. https://mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk/RS/ramanujan_rs.pdf
- Howell, S. T. (2017). Financing innovation: Evidence from R&D grants. American Economic Review, 107(4), 1136–1164. https://econpapers.repec.org/RePEc:aea:aecrev:v:107:y:2017:i:4:p:1136-64
- Jussim, L., & Harber, K. D. (2005). Teacher expectations and self-fulfilling prophecies: Knowns and unknowns, resolved and unresolved controversies. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 9(2), 131–155. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1207/s15327957pspr0902_3
- McNatt, D. B. (2000). Ancient Pygmalion joins contemporary management: A meta-analysis of the result. Journal of Applied Psychology, 85(2), 314–322. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.85.2.314
- Merton, R. K. (1968). The Matthew effect in science. Science, 159(3810), 56–63.
- Pallais, A. (2014). Inefficient hiring in entry-level labor markets. American Economic Review, 104(11), 3565–3599. https://www.nber.org/papers/w18917
- Spence, M. (1973). Job market signaling. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 87(3), 355–374.
- Troy, A., Moua, H., & Van Boekel, M. (2024). Wise feedback and trust in higher education. Psychology in the Schools. https://doi.org/10.1002/pits.23164
- Yeager, D. S., Purdie-Vaughns, V., Garcia, J., Apfel, N., Brzustoski, P., Master, A., Hessert, W. T., Williams, M. E., & Cohen, G. L. (2014). Breaking the cycle of mistrust: Wise interventions to provide critical feedback across the racial divide. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 143(2), 804–824. https://www.apa.org/pubs/journals/releases/xge-a0033906.pdf
Institutional and primary
- Neville, E. H. From obscurity to fame (reminiscence). Institute of Mathematical Sciences, Chennai. https://www.imsc.res.in/~rao/ramanujan/newnow/nevilletodews.htm
- Youth STEM 2030. In conversation with Hayat Sindi. https://www.youthstem2030.org/youth-stem-matters/read/in-conversation-with-hayat-sindi
Journalism and books
- Arab News. (2004, July 31). The scientist way. https://www.arabnews.com/node/253130
- Arab News, via Zawya. (2010, June 13). Sindi encourages women to pursue sciences. https://www.zawya.com/en/business/sindi-encourages-women-to-pursue-sciences-gaad1grg
- ABC7 Chicago. (2025, February 24). Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes' conviction upheld by US appeals court. https://abc7chicago.com/post/elizabeth-holmes-theranos-founders-conviction-upheld-us-appeals-court/15951712/
- The Daily Beast. (2011, October 21). Women in the World: Saudi innovator Hayat Sindi's science breakthrough. https://www.thedailybeast.com/women-in-the-world-saudi-innovator-hayat-sindis-science-breakthrough
- Fox Business. (2021, September 22). James Mattis, former defense chief, testifies at Elizabeth Holmes fraud trial. https://www.foxbusiness.com/technology/james-mattis-former-defense-chief-testifies-at-elizabeth-holmes-fraud-trial
- Ibarra, H., Carter, N. M., & Silva, C. (2010). Why men still get more promotions than women. Harvard Business Review, 88(9), 80–85. https://herminiaibarra.com/why-men-still-get-more-promotions-than-women/
- The National. (2022, February 11). Saudi scientist Hayat Sindi on making Arab women more visible in science. https://www.thenationalnews.com/gulf-news/2022/02/11/saudi-scientist-hayat-sindi-on-making-arab-women-more-visible-in-science/
- NBC News. (2021). James Mattis testifies he invested $85,000 in Theranos, ended up feeling "disappointed." https://www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/james-mattis-testifies-he-invested-85-000-theranos-ended-feeling-n1279917
- University of Amsterdam. (2018, April). Inequality in science funding. https://www.uva.nl/shared-content/uva/en/news/press-releases/2018/04/inequality-in-science-funding.html
- Wolfram, S. (2016, April 27). Who was Ramanujan? https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2016/04/who-was-ramanujan/
© Strategic Essay — Prince Researcher | For Academic and Editorial Use